Skip to main content

Oscar Bait month: Amelia

 A retrospective by Brooks Rich

Sometimes the Academy is right on the money. Occasionally I am confused on why a movie doesn't seem to hit when it comes to awards season. The early trailers come out and it seems inevitable this thing will be an awards player. No doubt in anyone's mind this is an Oscar player. Here's an awards film. This was the case when the first trailers for Amelia came out. A biopic about the world famous aviator starring two time Academy Award winner Hilary Swank? This thing can't miss. Spoiler alert. It missed. Amelia didn't crash and burn when it came to awards seasons. It didn't get off the runway. OK. I'm done with the plane puns. So the rest of the article is cleared for takeoff. Ok. Now I'm done.

The first problem is the movie is just kind of boring. Nothing really happens beyond just the beats of her life. There is nothing that feels cinematic about it. Mira Nair is a wonderful person I'm sure but her direction just comes across as flat to me. It's so by the numbers that it becomes dull. It doesn't even have that entertainment of so bad it's good. Nair directs it in such a paint by numbers way that is just becomes a shrug of a movie. An icon like Amelia Earhart deserves more than that and critics and audiences thought so as well. 

Even if it the movie doesn't do much itself sometimes a great performance can still make some buzz come awards season. A beloved actor or actress playing a real life person is like cat nip to the academy. Hilary Swank had already won two Best Actress Oscars so it was more then likely she would get nominated. But her performance as Earhart is nowhere near as good as her performances that won. Million Dollar Baby is not my favorite film but I can't deny she brings power and vulnerability to her role in that. And the film was the darling of the season so she just rode the wave to her second Oscar win. 

But her standout performance is Boys Don't Cry. This is one of those rare all time performances. She is just transcendent as Brandon Teena. Personally I think it's one of the ten best performances by an actress of all time. Of course I am not trying to compare Swank's performance as Amelia Earhart to her performance as Brandon Teena. Nothing she ever does will touch that. But there is just something that rubs me the wrong way about how she portrays Earhart. Yes she is doing a good impersonation but for me a good performance of a real life person goes beyond that. It only takes someone so far to do a great imitation. They also need to find a character there and Swank never really does with Earhart. If there was something there she would've cracked one of the five spots for Best Actress that year. The Oscars love past winners and she was still riding high then. But like the movie she was in, Swank never took off. 




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

John Travolta month: Saturday Night Fever

 A retrospective by Brooks Rich So this was not the big start of John Travolta's career. That would be the classic sitcom Welcome Back, Kotter. But this did elevate Travolta to another level. For any of you going oh come on. This silly movie with a disco soundtrack? Come on, Brooks. Just wait. Have you ever actually seen this? This isn't about disco. Disco just happens to be the music of choice. This about the kind of people who are kings at the dance clubs and then losers the rest of the time. There is a lot of darkness and truth in this film. So if you've never seen it please. Do yourself a flavor and check it out. Just watch it and then come back to read this.  This is a movie about the different types of people we become between our real lives and our weekend lives. Tony Manero is a regular working class guy in a Brooklyn neighborhood, struggling to make ends meet and dealing with his loving but at times overbearing family. He lives in the shadow of his priest brother. ...
1 comment
Read more

Forgotten Film Friday: Melinda and Melinda

 A retrospective by Brooks Rich I know Woody Allen is a complicated figure. He is a creep in a lot of ways and some people find his sexual weirdness to be too much. I get that. But on the blog I sometimes like to separate the art from artist. Not always to be sure. Jeepers Creepers will never be covered here because Victor Salva is a useless piece of human garbage. What he did I can't ignore. Allen I can push aside him being weird to cover him now and then. It's hard to write a film blog and not mention a Woody Allen film now and then. The man has some bangers. And I've always wanted to cover this film. The concept is so interesting and Allen post 2000 is fertile ground for Forgotten Film Friday. So let's look at the film and not Allen himself.  Melinda and Melinda is a dual narrative about a woman named Melinda, an underrated and brilliant Radha Mitchell, who shows up unexpectedly at a dinner party in New York. The film questions if life is inherently tragic or comic a...
Post a Comment
Read more

Ranking every Tintin comic

A ranking by Brooks Rich In order to expand the blog a little, we'll sometimes cover other media besides films. Film will still be our bread and butter but the blog will also cover tv, music, comics, books, and other forms of media. To start it off I will be ranking all 21 main comics in a beloved series of books form my childhood, The Adventures of Tintin. Created by Belgian cartoonist Herge, Tintin, who has literature's greatest cowlick, is a reporter who travels the world with his faithful dog Snowy, the best fictional dog of all time, chasing bad guys and sticking his nose in other's affairs. Tintin is often joined on his quests by Captain Haddock, his most trust human sidekick. I credit Tintin and the Hardy Boys for my current love of mystery novels. Ranking the 21 main Tintin comics is far more doable than ranking the original Hardy Boys runs. As a quick note I will not be counting the unfinished Tintin and Alph Art or Tintin in the Land of the Soviets or Tint...
Post a Comment
Read more